Skip to content

Roofing Underlayment Types: Felt vs Synthetic vs Peel-and-Stick

By Updated 3 min read

Line drawing illustrating roofing underlayment

Quick answer

Roofing underlayment comes in three main types: asphalt felt (#15 or #30), synthetic and self-adhered peel-and-stick. Synthetic is the most common choice today: it is light, tear resistant and one roll often covers 10 squares. Peel-and-stick is used at eaves, valleys and low slopes where ice dams or leaks are a risk.

Synthetic roll
≈10 squares
#15 felt roll
≈4 squares
Peel-and-stick roll
≈2 squares

Underlayment is the layer between the roof deck and the shingles. It is your backup when wind-driven rain gets under the shingles, and it keeps the deck dry during installation. Here are the main types, side by side, and how to figure out how many rolls you need.

Underlayment types compared

Type Typical coverage per roll Weight Exposure tolerance Cost level Best for
#15 asphalt felt ≈4 squares (400 sq ft) Heavy Days Low Budget jobs, under some tile
#30 asphalt felt ≈2 squares (200 sq ft) Heavier Days Low to mid Steeper roofs, more tear resistance
Synthetic often 10 squares (1,000 sq ft) Light Weeks to months (per product) Mid Most shingle and metal roofs
Peel-and-stick (self-adhered) ≈2 squares (200 sq ft) Heavy Varies High Eaves, valleys, low slopes, high-wind zones

Roll sizes vary by brand. Always confirm coverage on the label.

Asphalt felt

Felt paper is saturated with asphalt. It is cheap and familiar, but it tears more easily, can wrinkle when wet and gets slippery. #30 is thicker than #15 and holds up better while crews work.

Synthetic

Woven or spun polypropylene or polyethylene. It is far lighter per square, resists tearing, often has a walkable textured surface and comes in big rolls. Most shingle makers accept it, and it is the usual choice under metal roofs.

Peel-and-stick (ice and water barrier)

A rubberized asphalt membrane with a sticky back. It bonds to the deck and seals around nails. Building codes in cold climates require an ice barrier at the eaves where ice dams are common, typically from the edge to at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall.

Code basics worth knowing

  • Asphalt shingles on pitches from 2/12 up to 4/12 need two layers of underlayment under the model residential code.
  • In areas with a history of ice dams, an ice barrier is required at the eaves.
  • The shingle manufacturer’s instructions can require specific underlayment for the warranty.

Local code can be stricter, so check with your building department.

How many rolls do you need?

Rolls needed = roof area × 1.10 (overlaps) ÷ roll coverage.

Example: a 40 × 30 ft house with 12 inch overhangs at 6/12 has 1,503 sq ft of roof, so about 1,653 sq ft with overlaps.

Product Coverage Rolls
Synthetic 1,000 sq ft 2
#15 felt 400 sq ft 5
#30 felt 200 sq ft 9

Ice and water at the eaves: the two eaves are 42 ft each, 84 ft total. Two courses of a 3 ft wide membrane (to reach well inside the wall on this pitch) is 168 linear ft. At about 66 ft per roll, that is 3 rolls. Add more for valleys.

The roof calculator lists synthetic rolls in its materials list automatically.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Leaving felt exposed for weeks. It degrades and wrinkles. Plan to dry-in and shingle quickly.
  • Wrong lap direction. Each upper course must overlap the one below, like shingles, so water runs over the seams.
  • Skipping ice barrier in cold climates. Ice dams push water uphill under shingles. Peel-and-stick at the eaves is the fix.
  • Using standard felt under metal. Heat under metal can make asphalt felt stick and break down. See does a metal roof need underlayment.

For the deck beneath the underlayment, see roof sheathing thickness.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best roofing underlayment?

For most asphalt shingle roofs, a quality synthetic underlayment over the whole deck plus peel-and-stick ice and water membrane at the eaves and valleys is the common best practice. Follow the shingle maker's warranty requirements.

Is roofing underlayment waterproof?

Felt and synthetic underlayments are water resistant, not fully waterproof. They shed water that gets past the shingles. Self-adhered peel-and-stick membranes seal around nails and act as a waterproof barrier.

How long can roofing underlayment be exposed?

It depends on the product. Felt should be covered within days. Many synthetic underlayments are rated for weeks to several months of UV exposure. Check the product data sheet and cover it as soon as practical.

How many rolls of underlayment do I need?

Divide your roof area (plus about 10% for overlaps) by the roll coverage. For 1,503 sq ft of roof: 2 rolls of 10-square synthetic, or 5 rolls of #15 felt.

Figures are typical US values for planning. Building codes, product specs and local prices vary, so confirm with your local code office, the product's installation guide and a licensed roofer. See how we write and check our guides.